In Lancaster County, the roof problems that lead to insurance calls come in a few familiar shapes: shingles peeled off by a summer thunderstorm or a gusty nor'easter, the occasional hailstorm, and leaks from ice dams after a snowy stretch in January. Each one is handled a little differently, and knowing which one you are dealing with makes the conversation with your insurer much easier.
What follows is general background for homeowners. Your policy and your insurance agent decide what is covered.
The basic rule
Homeowners policies generally pay for sudden damage from a specific event. They generally do not pay for a roof that has worn out with age. So the most important part of any claim is showing what happened, when it happened, and what it damaged.
Wind damage
Wind damage is common around Lancaster, and it usually looks like:
- Shingles missing entirely, often along ridges, rakes, and edges
- Shingles that were lifted and creased, even if they settled back down
- Torn ridge caps
- Debris from fallen limbs
A creased shingle can look fine from the yard but has lost its seal and will likely blow off next time. Ask your roofer to check for creasing, not only for missing pieces. Our post on hail damage vs wind damage shows the difference in photos.
Hail damage
Hail is less frequent here than in the Plains, but it happens. Look for dents in gutters, downspouts, and the metal vents on the roof. On shingles, hail leaves dark round marks where granules were knocked loose. Wind and hail can damage the same roof in one storm, and each should be documented separately.
Ice dams
Ice dams form when snow melts on a warm upper roof, runs down, and refreezes at the cold eaves. Water backs up under the shingles and shows up as ceiling stains along exterior walls. Insurers can treat these leaks differently from storm damage, and repeated ice dams often point to attic ventilation or insulation problems. Ask your agent how your policy handles them.
What usually is and is not covered
| More likely covered | Less likely covered |
|---|---|
| Shingles blown off or creased in a dated storm | Shingles curling or cracking with age |
| Hail dents and bruises from a known storm | Granule loss across an older roof |
| Interior damage from a sudden storm leak | Long-term leaks that were never addressed |
| Damage from a tree limb that fell in a storm | Moss, rot, or deferred maintenance |
Older roofs and partial repairs
If your roof is older and only a few shingles blew off, the claim may only cover those shingles. When the original shingle is discontinued, matching gets tricky. Whether the insurer pays for a larger area to keep the roof looking uniform depends on your policy's wording.
Your deductible and upgrades
You will usually pay your deductible. Upgrades, like moving to a higher-grade shingle or adding features that were not there before, are usually on you as well. Ask for a written breakdown of the insurer's expected share and yours.
Documentation checklist
- The storm date, plus any weather alerts you saved
- Photos of each side of the house and close-ups of missing or damaged shingles
- Pictures of shingles or debris that landed in the yard
- Interior stains, with dates
- Your roof's approximate age and past repair receipts
How a claim usually goes
- 1.Protect the inside of the house if water is getting in.
- 2.Take photos before any temporary repair or tarp goes up.
- 3.Call your insurer to open a claim.
- 4.Get a roofer out for an inspection and ask for the findings in writing.
- 5.When the adjuster's estimate comes, compare it line by line with the roofer's report.
- 6.Ask questions before agreeing to any tear-off.
Our guide on filing a roof storm insurance claim in Pennsylvania covers the paperwork in more detail.
Watch out for storm chasers
After a big storm, crews from out of the area often go door to door. Be careful with blank contracts and pressure to sign right away. Ask for their Pennsylvania home improvement contractor registration, who pulls any needed permits, and who will answer if something leaks next year.
When to call
If shingles are missing, ceilings are stained, or you just are not sure, a documented inspection is a smart first step. Moonshot handles storm roof repair in Lancaster and surrounding towns. For any other roofing question, reach out to Moonshot, your roofing contractor in Lancaster.
FAQ
Are a few missing shingles worth a claim?
It depends on your deductible and the extent of the damage. A roofer's inspection and a quick call with your agent will help you decide.
Does insurance cover ice dam leaks?
Sometimes. Your agent can tell you how your policy treats them, and the cause of the leak matters.
Can a roofer promise my claim will be paid?
No. A roofer can document the damage. Your insurer makes the decision.
Keep reading